Is the American Jewish Committee finally getting it right on campus anti-Semitism?

With any luck, the AJC’s reversal may facilitate a unified  Jewish communal response to the resurgence of anti-Semitic incidents that have  been seen around the country, and especially in California, over the past  decade…”

AJC Gets It Right on Campus Anti-Semitism, At Last

David Harris Stood Behind Moves to Protect Jewish Students
By Kenneth L. Marcus

Published August 23, 2011, issue of September  02, 2011.  Jewish Daily Forward

In early August, the American Jewish Committee’s executive director, David  Harris, finally renounced his organization’s highly controversial joint  statement on campus anti-Semitism.

The initial statement, which AJC anti-Semitism expert Kenneth Stern had  published four months before, with Cary Nelson, president of the American  Association of University Professors, had generated considerable criticism  within the Jewish community. Interestingly, the AJC reversal coincided with  disturbing revelations in the University of California, Berkeley campus  anti-Semitism case.

The context for the AJC statement can be found in California. Jessica Felber  had gotten national attention earlier this year when she filed a federal lawsuit  alleging an anti-Semitic attack at the University of California’s flagship  Berkeley campus. In her federal complaint, the recent graduate detailed how a  Palestinian activist assaulted her on campus by ramming her from behind with a  loaded shopping cart. In mid-August, Felber revealed to the court that this  assault was part of an ugly pattern on that campus.  In another incident, a campus protester stopped a lecture to berate Felber for  the Hebrew lettering on her sweatshirt, yelling that she must be a “terrorist  supporter.” In a third, the head of Berkeley’s Students for Justice in Palestine  allegedly spat at her.

Felber is not alone; a second Berkeley student, Brian Maissy, has now joined  her lawsuit.  Maissy submitted a declaration describing the “terrifying” atmosphere on the Berkeley campus during “Apartheid Week,” when protesters  toting realistic-looking guns taunt passing students, demanding to know, “Are  you Jewish?”  Even more disturbing, Mel Gordon, a senior member of the Berkeley  faculty, is now supporting Felber’s lawsuit with written testimony that he had  been, “savagely beaten and spat upon” by the Students for Justice in Palestine.  Gordon described “serious injuries” that he received from blows to the  stomach.

Until recently, Felber had faced an unexpected adversary in her battle to  hold Berkeley accountable: the American Jewish Committee. The AJC-AAUP statement  had charged that some Jewish activists “are making the situation worse by  distorting the provisions of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and what  has been called the ‘working definition of anti-Semitism.’”

After mentioning Felber’s case and similar complaints at the university’s  Santa Cruz campus and Rutgers University, the AJC-AAUP letter added that “many” of the “recent allegations” of campus anti-Semitism “simply seek to silence  anti-Israel discourse and speakers.” Worse, the AJC-AAUP letter condemned some  of the allegations in these cases as not “unwarranted under Title VI,” but also “dangerous.”

The AJC-AAUP statement has been widely lambasted within the Jewish community.  Felber’s supporters criticized the statement’s censorship allegations as  unfounded, its Title VI interpretation as questionable and its public aspersions  as unnecessary. Many commentators, including this author, publicly urged the AJC  to retract the statement. The writer Jonathan Tobin bemoaned on Commentary’s  Contentions blog that “the letter that Kenneth Stern signed with Cary Nelson  stakes out a position that makes it unlikely that Title VI of the Civil Rights  Act will ever be applied to protect Jews from anti-Semitism on college  campuses.” David Horowitz, the conservative thinker, blasted Stern and Nelson  for misrepresenting the campus situation in their “haste to blame the Jewish  victims.” Just about the only supporters of the AJC-AAUP statement were  anti-Israel sources, such as The Electronic Intifada, which relied on the  Stern-Nelson letter when railing against efforts to eliminate anti-Semitism on  college campuses.

In an unusual move, Harris e-mailed Tammi Rossman-Benjamin (the lecturer who  filed the Santa Cruz complaint), renouncing his organization’s letter as “ill-advised.” Striking an apologetic note, Harris said that the AJC “regret[s]  the decision to have released it.” By way of explanation, Harris added that “AJC’s internal system of checks and balances did not function well in this  case.” Other AJC officials have confirmed that the AJC-AUUP statement is now  considered renounced by the organization. Harris’s candid acknowledgement of his  organization’s error provides a commendable resolution to what had been an  unfortunate blemish on the record of his organization and its widely respected  anti-Semitism expert.

The AJC’s sudden reversal also heals a rift that the AJC-AAUP statement had  created within the Jewish community. This is important, because Jewish communal  representatives continue to work with Obama administration officials on figuring  out how the federal government can best resolve hostile environment cases at  federally funded universities. Last October, the Education Department’s Office  for Civil Rights issued an important guidance letter affirming that it would  pursue anti-Semitism cases in the same way that it handles discrimination  against other groups.

The question now is whether the agency will properly enforce its new policy  when it comes to complicated cases involving both anti-Semitism and  anti-Israelism. With any luck, the AJC’s reversal may facilitate a unified  Jewish communal response to the resurgence of anti-Semitic incidents that have  been seen around the country, and especially in California, over the past  decade.

Kenneth Marcus is executive vice president of the Institute for Jewish & Community Research and a former staff director of the U.S. Commission on  Civil Rights. He is also the author of “Jewish Identity and Civil Rights in  America” (Cambridge University Press, 2010).

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: